Need help? We are here

Attached is 2 students debate paper we had to write on last week. All we have to do is read it and debate their paper.
Instructions:
Assess student 1 and student 2 paper. Did the overall paper adequately make the argument? Was there debate well supported? You can address them as student 1 and 2 what you are or disagree. Also, you discuss if their debate could been better, etc.